Just a short post.
Having been watching quite a few documentaries recently, mostly based around America in the last ten years or so, I have come to see the hidden agenda behind alot of these programs. Some, of course, are fine and present a mostly balanced view where at all possible. There are, however, quite a few that present only their information and often pretty much everything connected with it even vaguely. One example recently ran something like this: “Darwin wrote ‘Origins Of The Species’. This was picked up by the Eugenics movement. They created Social Darwinism. Therefore, Darwin was a Eugenicist with the group who want to take over the world”. This sort of stodgey logic is presented as fact, with little information to back it up. Indeed, atleast one documentary along these lines was entirely created around this method: Present one or two basic facts, imply their link with a third or fourth without any evidence and then present it as the truth. There is then little consideration of any alternative. Often, this is presented as counter-evidence to apparent reality, or against what is often refered to as propaganda. Indeed, it is often suggested that the main-stream news services are effectivly propaganda machines to hide the truth these individuals (and it is usually an individual) have uncovered.
And this is the problem with conspiracy-based documentaries. Others present, though certainly a one-sided view, documented facts and evidence for either side and to back up their theories. The conspiracy theories only really present their own propaganda, a mission-statement of what they want us (the viewer) to do. It is often refered to in terms of war; “We must combat…” and the subject of their film as a dictator, spreading a cause that would benefit only their own personal power.
For a cynic, this is always somewhat believable, and often evidence is quite compelling despite being circumstantial in nature. However, the lack of objectivity and real presentation of something approaching fact is a major obsticle and any important information contained in the film is often then ignored or discredited by the director/creator’s approach. Their, often quite valid, mission will continue to fail with these methods. Anything suspected of being a ‘conspiracy-theory’ inevitably winds up being ignored from the point at which it becomes apparent that it is more of a personal rant than a true documentary.
~Captain Bellamy